Sri Aurobindo
Letters of Sri Aurobindo
CWSA 27
Fragment ID: 6991
See letter itself (letter ID: 438)
Sri Aurobindo — Roy, Dilip Kumar
March 24, 1934
□ Hide link-numbers of differed places
Rabindranath Tagore [4]
Tagore has been a wayfarer towards the same goal as ours in his own way – that is the main thing, the exact stage of advance and putting of the steps are minor matters. His exact position as a poet or a prophet or anything else will be assigned by posterity and we need not be in haste to anticipate the final verdict. The immediate verdict after his departure or soon after it may very well be a rough one,– for this is a generation that seems to take a delight in trampling with an almost Nazi rudeness on the bodies of the Ancestors, especially the immediate ancestors. I have read with an interested surprise that Napoleon was only a bustling and self-important nincompoop all whose great achievements were done by others, that Shakespeare was “no great things” and that most other great men were by no means so great as the stupid respect and reverence of past ignorant ages made them out to be! What chance has then Tagore? But these injustices of the moment do not endure – in the end a wise and fair estimate is formed and survives the changes of time.
Tagore, of course, belonged to an age which had faith in its ideas and whose very denials were creative affirmations. That makes an immense difference. Your strictures on his later development may or may not be correct, but this mixture even was the note of the day and it expressed a tangible hope of a fusion into something new and true – therefore it could create. Now all that idealism8 has been smashed to pieces by the immense adverse Event and everybody is busy exposing its weakness, but nobody knows what to put in its place. A mixture of scepticism and slogans, “Heil-Hitler” and the Fascist salute and Five-Year Plan and the beating of everybody into one amorphous shape, a disabused denial of all ideals on one side and on the other a blind shut-my-eyes and shut-everybody’s-eyes plunge into the bog in the hope of finding some firm foundation there, will not carry us very far. And what else is there? Until new spiritual values are discovered, no great enduring creation is possible.
24 March 1934
1 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: After all he
2 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: the putting
3 Nest two sentences was ommitted here and were restored from Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: So let there be no clash, if possible. Besides he has had a long and brilliant day – I should like him to have as peaceful and undisturbed a sunset as may be.
4 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: death
5 SABCL, volume 22; Sri Aurobindo and Mother to Prithwi Singh; Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2; Letters of Sri Aurobindo. 2 Ser. As for your question, Tagore
6 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: may be correct, but this mixture even was the note
Sri Aurobindo and Mother to Prithwi Singh: too, was the note
7 Sri Aurobindo and Mother to Prithwi Singh; Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2; SABCL, volume 26: fusion
8 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: that
9 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: and its weaknesses exposed
10 SABCL, volume 22; Letters of Sri Aurobindo. 2 Ser. and the Five-Year-Plan
11 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: something there
12 Sri Aurobindo to Dilip.- Vol. 2: big
Current publication:
Sri Aurobindo. Letters on Poetry and Art // CWSA.- Volume 27.- Pondicherry: Sri Aurobindo Ashram, 2004.- 769 p.
Other publications:
Sri Aurobindo. On Himself // SABCL.- Volume 26. (≈ 35 vol. of CWSA)